Laura Michelle Owens & Clayton Echard: Difference between revisions

From The Laura Owens Court Cases
Jump to navigation Jump to search
VisualWikitext
 
(61 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[wikipedia:Clayton_Echard|Clayton Echard]], star of season 26 of ''The Bachelor,'' had a one-night fling (allegedly just oral sex) with Laura Owens on May 20, 2023. 11 days later, after he refuses to pursue a relationship with her, she claims she is pregnant. Laura drafted a dating contract to give to Clayton stating she would abort the baby if he agreed to date her, but he still refused. On August 1st, she took him to court to establish a "parenting plan" for the babies (now twins), and sent upwards of 500 emails and texts to him from more than a dozen different accounts. She went public with the case in September when he still refused to date her. She claims under oath on November 2nd that she is 24 weeks and just saw her OB a few days prior. Laura and Clayton are both granted orders of protection against one another. As of December 28th, she claimed she was "no longer pregnant", and sought to dismiss the court case. Because Clayton believed she fraudulently brought the situation into court and did not have evidence to prove she was actually pregnant with his child(ren), Clayton is seeking to be awarded attorney's fees.
[[wikipedia:Clayton_Echard|Clayton Echard]], star of season 26 of ''The Bachelor,'' had a one-night fling (allegedly just oral sex, according to him) with Laura Owens on May 20, 2023. 11 days later, after he refuses to pursue a relationship with her, she claims she is pregnant. Laura drafted a dating contract to give to Clayton stating she would abort the baby if he agreed to date her, but he still refused. On August 1st, she took him to court to establish a "parenting plan" for the babies (now twins), and sent upwards of 500 emails and texts to him from more than a dozen different accounts. She went public with the case in September when he still refused to date her. She claims under oath on November 2nd that she is 24 weeks and just saw her OB a few days prior. Laura and Clayton are both granted orders of protection against one another. As of December 28th, she claimed she was "no longer pregnant", and sought to dismiss the court case. Because Clayton believed she fraudulently brought the situation into court and did not have evidence to prove she was actually pregnant with his child(ren), Clayton sought to be awarded attorney's fees.
 
On Monday June 10th, 2024, the evidentiary hearing took place. On June 18th, Judge Mata gave her ruling, stating that the Court cannot find that Laura Michelle Owens was ever pregnant with Clayton Echard's child/children and cannot establish paternity of a non-confirmed pregnancy. She also found that Laura Owens filed the case in bad faith, not grounded in fact or based in law, provided false testimony, and attempted to extort Clayton Echard. The ruling states that Laura Owens must pay all of Clayton Echard's attorney fees and costs related to this case, but denied the attorney fees and costs for the IAH and OOP hearings. Furthermore, Judge Mata is referring this matter to the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office for review of Laura Owens' actions.


== Timeline of events ==
== Timeline of events ==
''A detailed timeline of all of Clayton Echard's court cases against Laura Owens, including screenshots of texts and emails, can be found at [http://justiceforclaytontimeline.com justiceforclaytontimeline.com.].''


=== 2023 ===
=== 2023 ===
Line 8: Line 11:
'''May 9:''' Laura Owens creates an LLC for the purpose of Real Estate and Rental and Leasing. <ref>https://ecorp.azcc.gov/BusinessSearch/BusinessInfo?entityNumber=23526876</ref>
'''May 9:''' Laura Owens creates an LLC for the purpose of Real Estate and Rental and Leasing. <ref>https://ecorp.azcc.gov/BusinessSearch/BusinessInfo?entityNumber=23526876</ref>


'''May ?''': Owens reaches out to Clayton Echard on LinkedIn for real estate assistance<sup>[''citation needed'']</sup>.
'''May 17''': Owens reaches out to Clayton Echard on LinkedIn for real estate assistance.<ref>[[:File:3 26 motion for joint hearing Redacted (1).pdf]]</ref>


'''May 20:''' The two meet in person for the first time. The two have an “intimate encounter,” which Echard describes as “only oral sex.” The following day, Echard tells Owens that the hook up was a "mistake." <ref>https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fbof87l9rpsyb1.jpg</ref>
'''May 20:''' After an exchange of flirty text messages, which Clayton claims involved a racy photo sent by Laura, Clayton invites Laura over. The two have an “intimate encounter,” which Echard describes as “only oral sex.” The following day, Echard tells Owens that the hook up was a "mistake." <ref>https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fbof87l9rpsyb1.jpg</ref>


'''May 21''': Clayton makes his intentions clear, that he does not want to pursue a relationship with her. He apologizes for crossing the professional/personal boundary. She breaks down in tears and refuses to accept it. She asks to have him continue to be her realtor.<ref name=":2">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zakKq3kUloc</ref>
'''May 21''': Clayton makes his intentions clear, that he does not want to pursue a relationship with her. He apologizes for crossing the professional/personal boundary. She breaks down in tears and refuses to accept it. She asks to have him continue to be her realtor.<ref name=":2">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zakKq3kUloc</ref>
Line 18: Line 21:
'''May 25:''' Echard asks Owens to leave him alone, informing her that he is considering contacting the police. He blocks her phone number.<ref name=":2" />
'''May 25:''' Echard asks Owens to leave him alone, informing her that he is considering contacting the police. He blocks her phone number.<ref name=":2" />


'''June 1:''' 11 days after their “intimate encounter,” Owens emails Echard a photo of her first positive pregnancy test. <ref name=":3">https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf</ref>
'''May 30:''' Laura states that she took a pregnancy test before a CT scan and it was negative.<ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/2/27/1-25_Woodnick_response_Redacted_compressed_%281%29.pdf</ref>
 
'''May 31:''' Laura takes a home pregnancy (hCG) test again. She at first states that it was negative<ref name=":4" />, but later claims that she saw a "faint" positive line<ref name=":5">[[:File:2024.04.16 - Affidavit of Laura Owens.pdf]]</ref>, so decided to go get another test done at a medical facility the next day.
 
'''June 1:''' Laura went to Banner Urgent Care for a pregnancy (hCG) test, and tested positive. 11 days after their “intimate encounter,” Owens emails Echard a photo of her first positive pregnancy test. <ref name=":3">https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf</ref>
 
'''June 4:''' Clayton reaches out to Jan Black (Laura's mother). Clayton asks her several times via text if they can talk on the phone, but she refuses and says she will only talk to him if he gives her daughter a chance at a relationship. <ref>[[:File:Texts messages between clayton and Jan.pdf]]</ref>


'''June 17:''' Echard purchases a pregnancy test and asked Owens to take in front of him to confirm the pregnancy. She goes to the bathroom and the result comes out positive. <ref name=":3" />
'''June 17:''' Echard purchases a pregnancy test and asked Owens to take in front of him to confirm the pregnancy. She goes to the bathroom and the result comes out positive. <ref name=":3" />
'''June 21:''' Clayton emails Laura, citing research he's looked into that some seizure medication can give false positives on pregnancy tests. Laura denies that. Clayton also states in this email that they only had oral sex (something he has consistently stated).<ref name=":4" />


'''June 27:''' Owens' "Iceland story" is published in Chicken Soup for the Soul. <ref>https://chartable.com/podcasts/chicken-soup-for-the-soul-with-amy-newmark/episodes/147337085-strangers-on-a-plane-and-the-lifesaving-power-of-kindness</ref>
'''June 27:''' Owens' "Iceland story" is published in Chicken Soup for the Soul. <ref>https://chartable.com/podcasts/chicken-soup-for-the-soul-with-amy-newmark/episodes/147337085-strangers-on-a-plane-and-the-lifesaving-power-of-kindness</ref>


'''July 1:''' Owens emails Echard to try and convince him to sleep with her and told him that she would get an abortion if he agreed to date her. <ref name=":3" />
'''June 28:''' Laura emails Clayton to say she's "having the baby if I don't hear back from you tonight". She says in her email that she wants to date him and will get an abortion if he agrees to, or she will throw the abortion pills away if he refuses. He responded saying he wants nothing to do with her and to please leave him alone.<ref>[[:File:Having the baby if I don't hear back tonight emails.pdf]]</ref>


'''July 2:''' Owens emails Echard’s parents inviting them to her ultrasound. <ref name=":3" />
'''July 2:''' Owens emails Echard’s parents inviting them to her ultrasound. <ref name=":3" /> Laura said in her affidavit on 4/16/24 that she went to Planned Parenthood in Mission Viejo on this day. <ref name=":5" /> Planned Parenthood replies to Gregg Woodnick, stating that Laura Owens did have an appt at a location on July 2nd, but she canceled it.<ref>https://padlet.com/haybales/laura-owens-timeline-qz4pd706aw8m8zv3/wish/LNV1Q7Em1BY3Wmq3</ref> According to Laura's testimony at the June 10th trial, she changed her story and stated that she actually went to a Planned Parenthood in LA on this day. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNtMoU42K0E</ref> ''(It should be noted that Planned Parenthoods in LA are closed on Sundays.)''


'''July 7''': Owens sends Clayton a photo of her alleged ultrasound. You can view that ultrasound during Clayton's interview with the Viall Files at the [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zakKq3kUloc 1 hr and 23 minute mark here].  
'''July 7''': Owens sends Clayton a photo of her alleged ultrasound. You can view that ultrasound during Clayton's interview with the Viall Files at the [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zakKq3kUloc 1 hr and 23 minute mark here].  


''Note: The ultrasound shows the date that the encounter happened, not the date of the last missed period, which is what doctors go by when determining fetal age.''
''Note: The ultrasound attempts to date the pregnancy using the date that the intimate encounter happened, not the date of the last menstrual period, which is the standard of care for pregnancy dating across OB/GYNs.''
 
'''July 23:''' According to Laura Owens and her attorney David S. Gingras, '''Laura passes two "less than hand-sized fetal sacs" on this date'''. She allegedly sought medical attention via a telehealth doc and they told her there was no need to go in. She also allegedly texted photos of these fetal sacs to her sister on this day, and sent them to her doctor. In later filings, she claimed that she and her sister Laura Navarro had deleted the pictures, and refused to turn them over in discovery.<ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/b/bf/Woodnick_response_4_10_compressed-1-9.pdf</ref>
 
'''July 24:''' Laura allegedly had a scheduled appointment with Dr. Makhoul to "hear the heartbeat". Since there is no documentation of this appointment, it is assumed that she canceled it.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r62n2sMW_K0&t=2365s</ref>
 
'''July 31:''' Laura files a police report with Scottsdale PD, stating Clayton has been "threatening, intimidating, verbally abusing, endangering, and extorting her". She wanted to have it on record. Refers to Clayton as the father of her unborn twins. This is also when the officer suggests blocking his number, but she said that she didn't want to because she "wants to know what he's thinking". <ref>[[:File:2023.07.31 LO Police Call.pdf]]</ref>


'''August 1:''' Owens files Petition to Establish Paternity against Echard in Maricopa County Family Court. <ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
'''August 1:''' Owens files Petition to Establish Paternity against Echard in Maricopa County Family Court. <ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
Line 37: Line 54:


'''August 8''': Owens files first "Motion to Communicate" and Child Support Worksheet<ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
'''August 8''': Owens files first "Motion to Communicate" and Child Support Worksheet<ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
'''August 14:''' Laura cancels her appt. set with Dr. Makhoul (an ob/gyn) for the following day, stating she has covid. <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/e/e1/REDACTED_Motion_for_extension_of_time_to_respond_Redacted.pdf</ref>


'''August 17''': Owens emails Echard, warning that she will be filing a "Motion to Contempt" if he does not agree to meet up with her privately.<ref>[[:File:2023.08.23 Motion for contempt Redacted-compressed.pdf|Motion for Contempt, Page 22]] </ref>
'''August 17''': Owens emails Echard, warning that she will be filing a "Motion to Contempt" if he does not agree to meet up with her privately.<ref>[[:File:2023.08.23 Motion for contempt Redacted-compressed.pdf|Motion for Contempt, Page 22]] </ref>
Line 42: Line 61:
'''August 21''': Echard answers Owens' Petition to Establish Paternity.<ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
'''August 21''': Echard answers Owens' Petition to Establish Paternity.<ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>


'''August 23''': Owens files Motion for Contempt.<ref>[[:File:2023.08.23 Motion for contempt Redacted-compressed.pdf|2023.08.23 Motion for Contempt]]</ref>
'''August 23''': Laura initially scheduled their respective tests with Ravgen, but ended up canceling them.<ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/e/ed/Motion_to_communicate_8_2023.pdf</ref> Clayton was unaware of the cancelation until he called the day before. Also on this day, Laura Michelle Owens files a Motion for Contempt.<ref>[[:File:2023.08.23 Motion for contempt Redacted-compressed.pdf|2023.08.23 Motion for Contempt]]</ref>


'''August 27''': Owens completes 4 Hour Co-Parenting and Divorce Class and files Parent Education Certificate with the Family Court.<ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
'''August 27''': Owens completes 4 Hour Co-Parenting and Divorce Class and files Parent Education Certificate with the Family Court.<ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
Line 58: Line 77:
'''September 18:''' Owens goes to the Sun and Medium with an anonymous article. <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf</ref> <ref>https://www.the-sun.com/tv/9120018/bachelor-clayton-echard-ex-paternity-test-pregnant-twins/</ref> <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf</ref> This was released the 2nd day of Echard filming a new pickleball show.<ref name=":2" />
'''September 18:''' Owens goes to the Sun and Medium with an anonymous article. <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf</ref> <ref>https://www.the-sun.com/tv/9120018/bachelor-clayton-echard-ex-paternity-test-pregnant-twins/</ref> <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf</ref> This was released the 2nd day of Echard filming a new pickleball show.<ref name=":2" />


'''September 22:''' Owens posts "''I am the anonymous woman in the Clayton scandal. Here's the proof. Here's my story:''" on Reddit<ref>https://www.reddit.com/r/thebachelor/comments/16oxwn3/i_am_the_anonymous_woman_in_the_clayton_scandal/</ref>. She provides other Redditors with links to her public Dropbox with photos of her pregnant belly and texts/emails from Echard.
'''September 21:''' Owens posts "''I am the anonymous woman in the Clayton scandal. Here's the proof. Here's my story:''" on Reddit<ref name=":4">https://www.reddit.com/r/thebachelor/comments/16oxwn3/i_am_the_anonymous_woman_in_the_clayton_scandal/</ref> with a link to [https://archive.is/Jmhno her original Medium article of the same name]. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxxwzqd_F20 She provides other Redditors with links to her public Dropbox with photos of her pregnant belly and texts/emails from Echard].
 
'''September 21:''' Clayton posts on his Instagram story a receipt from Ravgen for scheduling the paternity test. Clayton also posts that other individuals have identical accusations against them from this individual.
 
'''September 22:''' Fortify Legal Services sends a cease and desist letter to Clayton regarding the Instagram story mentioned above.
 
'''September 22:''' Laura calls Scottsdale PD regarding Clayton being on Reddit. Her mother, Jan Black, can be heard in the background calling Clayton a "joke".<ref>[[:File:E2309220172.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''September 26:''' Clayton files Petition for Injunction Against Harassment against Laura Michelle Owens.<ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/7/76/Clayton%27s_Injunction_Against_Harassment_against_Laura.pdf</ref>


'''September 27:''' Echard takes his side of paternity test. Owens is photographed competing in an Equestrian jumping competition — allegedly 20 weeks pregnant with twins. No baby bump seen. <ref>https://www.reddit.com/r/BachelorNation/comments/17lg27v/laura_michelle_owens_of_the_nobody_told_me/</ref> <ref>https://mccoolproofs.pixieset.com/2023blenheiminternationaljumpingfestival/p/OTkzNjYyNTIwMA==-MzAzODY0Mzc2NQ/</ref>
'''September 27:''' Echard takes his side of paternity test. Owens is photographed competing in an Equestrian jumping competition — allegedly 20 weeks pregnant with twins. No baby bump seen. <ref>https://www.reddit.com/r/BachelorNation/comments/17lg27v/laura_michelle_owens_of_the_nobody_told_me/</ref> <ref>https://mccoolproofs.pixieset.com/2023blenheiminternationaljumpingfestival/p/OTkzNjYyNTIwMA==-MzAzODY0Mzc2NQ/</ref>
Line 66: Line 93:
''It is important to note that all of Owens’ DNA tests returned the same result of “'''little to no fetal DNA.'''”''
''It is important to note that all of Owens’ DNA tests returned the same result of “'''little to no fetal DNA.'''”''


According to Echard, Owens then sends him an ultrasound that he believes was doctored. He also claims she later refused to call the OBGYN’s office to verify the ultrasound’s authenticity during their early resolution conference. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn-szJXMtr4</ref>
'''October 6:''' Owens files OOP against Echard. You can watch that short hearing [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ph2It38CRw here], or read the transcript [[:File:Owens v Echard - October 6 2023 Hearing Transcript.pdf|here]].
 
'''October 6:''' Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD about Clayton harassing her online. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNDaVf-eLsc</ref>
 
'''October 7:''' Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that Greg Gillespie is behind Reddit accounts that are posting about her.<ref>[[:File:E2310070115.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''October 8:''' Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that Greg Gillespie is behind Reddit accounts that are posting about her.<ref>[[:File:E2310080332.pdf]]</ref>


Owens files OOP against Echard.
'''October 9:''' Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that Greg Gillespie is behind Reddit accounts that are posting about her.<ref>[[:File:E2310090293.pdf]]</ref>


'''October 13:''' [[Dave Neal]] breaks the story that on October 11th, Owens had circulated her alleged sonogram video to the media, which was later proved to be an edited 6 year old sonogram from an unrelated Youtuber. There were several things off about the ultrasound video, which are shown on Neal's video. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GyMuqht4sc&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=8</ref> Owens later claims [[Greg Gillespie: June 2021 - October 2023: Scottsdale, Arizona|Greg Gillespie]] hacked into her account and released the fake sonogram.
'''October 10:''' Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that she was "violated cyberly" (she doesn't state by whom).<ref>[[:File:E2310100345.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''October 13:''' [[Dave Neal]] breaks the story that on October 11th, Owens had circulated her alleged sonogram video to Clayton as well as to the media, which was later proved to be an edited 6 year old sonogram from an unrelated Youtuber. There were several things off about the ultrasound video, which are shown on Neal's video. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GyMuqht4sc&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=8</ref> Owens later claims [[Greg Gillespie: June 2021 - October 2023: Scottsdale, Arizona|Greg Gillespie]] hacked into her account and released the fake sonogram.


'''October 16:''' Laura Owens has an HCG test done, showing that her HCG levels on this day, at 21+ weeks pregnant, were 102 mIU/mL.<ref>[[:File:Image.webp]]</ref>
'''October 16:''' Laura Owens has an HCG test done, showing that her HCG levels on this day, at 21+ weeks pregnant, were 102 mIU/mL.<ref>[[:File:Image.webp]]</ref>


'''October 19:''' Owens sends Neal a cease and desist letter for his coverage. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VHnSaFYkd20&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=10</ref>
'''October 19:''' Laura sends Dave Neal a cease and desist letter for his coverage. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VHnSaFYkd20&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=10</ref>
 
'''October 19:''' Laura also calls the Scottsdale PD on Clayton, stating that Clayton has violated his OOP by posting the October 6th Instagram story. It should be noted that the OOP did not go in effect until October 17th.<ref>[[:File:2023.10.19 - Police Report - Owens accusing Echard of violating PO.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''October 24:''' The first part of the Echard vs. Owens IAH case takes place. Laura appears virtually, while her lawyer and Clayton, who is self-representing at the time, appear in court. Judge Gialketsis determines that the hearing must continue on November 2nd because Laura's lawyer failed to give Clayton some of the documents in advance. You can watch the hearing [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn-szJXMtr4&t=2444s here].
 
'''October 25:''' Owens vs. Echard OOP case takes place. Laura appears in person with a large pregnant bump. Judge Doody upholds the OOP against Clayton, specifically stating that costume image released on Reddit being the main cause for upholding it. Clayton denies that he is the one that uploaded that image. Laura testifies to Judge Doody that Clayton is the only one that has that image, so could be the only person that could have done that. She failed to testify that she made her dropbox public, which means that dozens of Redditors also had access to the image. She also states 2 weeks later in a police report that Greg Gillespie was the one that uploaded the costume image.<ref>[[:File:9.27.23 GG police report.pdf]]</ref><ref>[[:File:The Gillespie connection - color redacted - share.pdf]]</ref> It's also worth nothing that the person that did create the image stated on X that they were the one responsible for the image, and were verified to be neither Clayton nor Greg. You can watch the hearing [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3kECGOLcfs&t=637s here.]


'''October 26:''' Owens files for a temporary restraining order against Neal. The judge denies the request on first amendment concerns. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MVr0VAupjk&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=15</ref>
'''October 26:''' Owens files for a temporary restraining order against Neal. The judge denies the request on first amendment concerns. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MVr0VAupjk&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=15</ref>


'''November 2:''' Echard wins his injunction against harassment hearing. Owens states in cross-examination that she was 24 weeks pregnant and had just seen her OB "last Friday". Owens is seen drinking an energy drink during the hearing. Echard claims that Owens got him fired from speaking gigs and reported him to the Real Estate commission. Judge sides with Echard due to the 500+ messages he received from her after he asked her to stop contacting him and blocked her. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r62n2sMW_K0&t=16s</ref>
'''November 1:''' Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD claiming that she's being stalked and harassed online, and that she suspects it's either Greg or Clayton. She also states that she thinks somebody tried to break into her rental property.<ref>[[:File:E2311010426.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''November 2:''' The second part of Clayton's IAH takes place. Clayton is now represented by Deandra Arena from Woodnick Law. Echard wins his injunction against harassment hearing. Owens states in cross-examination that she was 24 weeks pregnant and had just seen her OB "last Friday". Owens is seen drinking an energy drink during the hearing, which is unadvised to do during a pregnancy. Echard claims that Owens got him fired from speaking gigs and reported him to the Real Estate commission. Judge Gialketsis sides with Echard due to the 500+ messages/emails he received from her after he asked her to stop contacting him and blocked her. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r62n2sMW_K0&t=16s</ref> You can watch the hearing [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r62n2sMW_K0&t=2601s here].


'''November 3:''' Neal is served lawsuit from Owens alleging harassment and revenge porn. The photo she cites as revenge porn, was shared by Owens in her public Dropbox “evidence” folder, which she sent to various media outlets, as well as in Bachelor related subreddits. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2yNFYlt2A4&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=21</ref>
'''November 3:''' Dave Neal is served lawsuit from Owens alleging harassment and revenge porn. The photo she cites as revenge porn, was shared by Owens in her public Dropbox “evidence” folder, which she sent to various media outlets, as well as in Bachelor related subreddits. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2yNFYlt2A4&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=21</ref>


'''November 6:''' Video surfaces of Owens’ alleged baby belly moving wildly during court hearing against Echard, 27 days after she was photographed without a bump at horse jumping competition. <ref>https://imgur.com/a/wRzEynh</ref>
'''November 6:''' Video surfaces of Owens’ alleged baby belly moving wildly during court hearing against Echard, 27 days after she was photographed without a bump at horse jumping competition. <ref>https://imgur.com/a/wRzEynh</ref>
Line 89: Line 132:


'''November 14:''' Owens sends mass email to podcasters threatening to sue them for defamation if they cover the case without platforming her. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-jWUDnG9s0&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=23</ref>
'''November 14:''' Owens sends mass email to podcasters threatening to sue them for defamation if they cover the case without platforming her. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-jWUDnG9s0&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=23</ref>
'''November 14:''' Laura Michelle Owens attends a dr appt at MomDoc. They give her a pregnancy test and confirm that she is not pregnant.<ref>[[:File:Petitioners Expert Disclosure Statement Redacted 2.0 Part3.pdf]]</ref>


'''November 15:''' Reality Steve offers Owens a platform to share her story. She does not accept his offer and instead threatens to sue him.
'''November 15:''' Reality Steve offers Owens a platform to share her story. She does not accept his offer and instead threatens to sue him.
Line 104: Line 149:
'''December 8:''' Owens publishes blog post to Medium titled "Unveiling the Unbearable: My Battle Against Cyberbullying and Online Harassment | by Laura Owens" <ref>https://medium.com/@laura_owens/unveiling-the-unbearable-my-battle-against-cyberbullying-and-online-harassment-eef20c9974dc</ref>
'''December 8:''' Owens publishes blog post to Medium titled "Unveiling the Unbearable: My Battle Against Cyberbullying and Online Harassment | by Laura Owens" <ref>https://medium.com/@laura_owens/unveiling-the-unbearable-my-battle-against-cyberbullying-and-online-harassment-eef20c9974dc</ref>


'''December 12:''' Echard files a motion in family court to extend the dismissal date, to definitively, on record, settle if he is or is not the father of Laura Owens' alleged twins.<ref name=":0">https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref>
'''December 8:''' Laura calls the Scottsdale PD claiming that Clayton has violated his OOP by posting something online. <ref>[[:File:2023.12.08 - LO Police Report.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''December 12:''' Echard files a motion in family court to extend the dismissal date, to definitively, on record, settle if he is or is not the father of Laura Owens' alleged twins.<ref name=":0">https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114</ref> Also, a welfare check is done on Laura Michelle Owens, after an anonymous friend calls the Scottsdale PD because of her Medium article written on 12/8. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ABioi8KbM6s You can watch the body cam footage of this welfare check here.] (Note: They never actually see Laura during this welfare check, just her mother.)


'''December 20:''' Owens posts a public video on her Facebook page which opens with "My name is Laura Owens..." and proceeds to speak for over 6 minutes about being "cyberbullied". The video is shot from her neck up. The sounds she makes are of a crying nature, but no tears are actually seen for the entirety of the video. She specifically calls out Neal, Reality Steve, and "Reddit sleuths" for alleged cyberbullying. Owens also shared Patreon paid subscriber private stream footage of Neal saying things about her over the past few months without any context. Once again, let it be known that Neal has never once said her name (he refers to her as Jane Doe) or shown any photos of her. After about a half-hour, the video disappears from her public Facebook page and she claims that it was only intended for her close friends and family (her beginning the video with "My name is Laura Owens..." seems to dispute this claim).
'''December 20:''' Owens posts a public video on her Facebook page which opens with "My name is Laura Owens..." and proceeds to speak for over 6 minutes about being "cyberbullied". The video is shot from her neck up. The sounds she makes are of a crying nature, but no tears are actually seen for the entirety of the video. She specifically calls out Neal, Reality Steve, and "Reddit sleuths" for alleged cyberbullying. Owens also shared Patreon paid subscriber private stream footage of Neal saying things about her over the past few months without any context. Once again, let it be known that Neal has never once said her name (he refers to her as Jane Doe) or shown any photos of her. After about a half-hour, the video disappears from her public Facebook page and she claims that it was only intended for her close friends and family (her beginning the video with "My name is Laura Owens..." seems to dispute this claim).
Line 110: Line 157:
'''December 21:''' The Medium article by Regina Phalange was taken down by Medium<ref>https://archive.is/12Pfh</ref>. Interesting that Medium continues to leave up her defamatory post about Echard and Dave, then takes down Regina's cogent rebuttal of Owens' post.
'''December 21:''' The Medium article by Regina Phalange was taken down by Medium<ref>https://archive.is/12Pfh</ref>. Interesting that Medium continues to leave up her defamatory post about Echard and Dave, then takes down Regina's cogent rebuttal of Owens' post.


'''December 23:''' Chase J. Jones (widely believed to Owens - see below for details) submits to have his Google and Patreon subpoenas quashed, claiming that he has nothing to do with the case. <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/6/60/2023.12.19_Chase_Jones_motion_to_quash_subpoenas.pdf</ref> Dave's lawyer has reached out to "Chase J. Jones" several times, asking for a quick FaceTime to verify he is real and put this matter to bed, but has been met with silence on the other end.
'''December 23:''' Chase J. Jones (widely believed to be Owens - see below for details) submits to have his Google and Patreon subpoenas quashed, claiming that he has nothing to do with the case. <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/6/60/2023.12.19_Chase_Jones_motion_to_quash_subpoenas.pdf</ref> Dave's lawyer has reached out to "Chase J. Jones" several times, asking for a quick FaceTime to verify he is real and put this matter to bed, but has been met with silence on the other end.


'''December 25:''' Laura Owens sends a cease and desist letter to TikTok/YouTube personality, Liz Neptune, regarding the use of a video Owens had posted to Facebook that had been used in a TikTok video by a different creator (not Liz Neptune). That creator is not affiliated with Liz in any way, yet Owens claims that she has proof that they are, but has not provided that proof. Owens and Neptune engage in a brief email correspondence, ending with Neptune telling Owens to never contact her again. Owens reported the correspondence as harassment to Liz's local Sherriff's department. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xQlbdtfoOE4</ref>
'''December 25:''' Laura Owens sends a cease and desist letter to TikTok/YouTube personality, Liz Neptune, regarding the use of a video Owens had posted to Facebook that had been used in a TikTok video by a different creator (not Liz Neptune). That creator is not affiliated with Liz in any way, yet Owens claims that she has proof that they are, but has not provided that proof. Owens and Neptune engage in a brief email correspondence, ending with Neptune telling Owens to never contact her again. Owens reported the correspondence as harassment to Liz's local Sherriff's department. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xQlbdtfoOE4</ref>
Line 119: Line 166:
'''January 2:''' A new article<ref>https://www.the-sun.com/tv/9991743/bachelor-clayton-echard-fling-no-longer-pregnant-paternity-test/</ref> about the case is published in The Sun. Owens responds to the article, stating: "that she 'firmly stands by everything' she had previously claimed and that she had a positive pregnancy test at one point, which was also documented in court docs, that 'confirmed' her pregnancy and 'was corroborated by a test at a medical facility.'"
'''January 2:''' A new article<ref>https://www.the-sun.com/tv/9991743/bachelor-clayton-echard-fling-no-longer-pregnant-paternity-test/</ref> about the case is published in The Sun. Owens responds to the article, stating: "that she 'firmly stands by everything' she had previously claimed and that she had a positive pregnancy test at one point, which was also documented in court docs, that 'confirmed' her pregnancy and 'was corroborated by a test at a medical facility.'"


Owens files to quash her deposition from Echard and his attorneys. Owens' new attorney, Lexi Lindvall, withdraws as counsel just one week after she takes on the case. Shortly thereafter, Cory Keith becomes Laura's new attorney. Evidentiary Hearing is set by the court for February 27th. <ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/CivilCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=CV2023-054291</ref>
Laura also contacted the Scottsdale PD about Clayton's comments to The Sun, stating it was a violation of his OOP. <ref>[[:File:2024.01.02 - LO Police Call.pdf]]</ref>
 
Laura Michelle Owens files to quash her deposition from Echard and his attorneys. Owens' new attorney, Lexi Lindvall, withdraws as counsel just one week after she takes on the case. Shortly thereafter, Cory Keith becomes Laura's new attorney. Evidentiary Hearing is set by the court for February 27th. <ref>https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/CivilCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=CV2023-054291</ref>


'''January 17''': Laura fails to show up for her deposition. <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/d/d7/Notice_of_non-appearancePDF.pdf</ref>
'''January 17''': Laura fails to show up for her deposition. <ref>https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/d/d7/Notice_of_non-appearancePDF.pdf</ref>
'''January 18:''' Laura calls the Scottsdale PD about harassing phone calls she's been receiving.<ref>[[:File:2024.01.18 - LO Police Call.pdf]]</ref>
'''January 26:''' Laura Michelle Owens formed a company named Stylete, LLC. The description of this company is unknown.


'''February 2''': Clayton shows up for his deposition. Laura attends it as well. <ref name=":1">https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/f/f5/2024.02.06_Expedited_Motion_to_Continue_Trial_and_Motion_for_Additional_Trial_Time.pdf</ref>
'''February 2''': Clayton shows up for his deposition. Laura attends it as well. <ref name=":1">https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/f/f5/2024.02.06_Expedited_Motion_to_Continue_Trial_and_Motion_for_Additional_Trial_Time.pdf</ref>
Line 127: Line 180:
'''February 6:''' Clayton's lawyer files expedited motion to continue trial and motion for additional trial time.<ref name=":1" />
'''February 6:''' Clayton's lawyer files expedited motion to continue trial and motion for additional trial time.<ref name=":1" />


'''February 7:''' Laura Owens receives harassing Facebook posts from what appears to be a troll account. She calls the police about these Facebook posts. Audio of this public call can be found [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izfXqYHT1HA&ab_channel=SchnitzelNinja here]. The public Scottsdale Police report can also be accessed [[:File:2024.02.07 LO Police Report.jpg|here]]:
'''February 7:''' Laura Owens receives harassing Facebook posts from what appears to be a troll account. She calls the police about these Facebook posts. Audio of this public call can be found [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izfXqYHT1HA&ab_channel=SchnitzelNinja here]. The public Scottsdale Police report can also be accessed [[:File:2024.02.07 LO Police Report.jpg|here]].


'''February 11''': The account Justice for Clayton has been banned from twitter (X).
'''February 11''': The account Justice for Clayton was banned from twitter (X), but reinstated a few days later.


'''February 12''': Clayton's lawyer files expedited motion to set virtual status conference. <ref name=":0" />
'''February 12''': Clayton's lawyer files expedited motion to set virtual status conference. <ref name=":0" />


'''February 14:''' On Laura's alleged due date, she posts a blog post about miscarriage that is so cruel, insensitive, heartless, immature, and irresponsible that we will not link it here.
'''February 14:''' On Laura's alleged due date, she posts a blog post about miscarriage that is so cruel, insensitive, heartless, immature, and irresponsible that we will not link it here. Also on this day, Laura called the Scottsdale PD about alleged online harassment. She specifically asks if her call cannot be public record, but the 911 operator tells her that 911 calls are public record. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LGFCFpAltk You can listen to the call here.]


'''February 15:''' Status conference is set for February 21st.<ref name=":0" /> The account Justice for Clayton has been reinstated on twitter (X).
'''February 15:''' Status conference is set for February 21st.<ref name=":0" />  


'''February 16:''' Judge denied Laura's motion to quash her deposition. <ref name=":0" /> The next few days, the Justice for Clayton sub on Reddit was banned and reinstated twice.
'''February 16:''' Judge denied Laura's motion to quash her deposition. <ref name=":0" /> The next few days, the Justice for Clayton sub on Reddit was banned and reinstated twice.


'''February 21:''' Status Conference is held. Laura Owens and Clayton Echard were present. Judge denied: Motion to Seal and Dismiss. Judge approved: Extend time of hearing and Owens needs to be deposed. Judge set Deposition to be on March 1st.  June 10th is new hearing date. Laura Owens claims in this hearing that she thought she was pregnant in November, but found out later that she had a miscarriage "1 to 2 months prior". Her statement from the November 2nd hearing contradicts that claim. Steve Carbone (Reality Steve) also claims that in correspondence with her, she claims she was still pregnant in December. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX5bm_6llB4</ref>
'''February 21:''' Status Conference is held. Laura Owens and Clayton Echard were present. Judge denied: Motion to Seal and Dismiss. Judge approved: Extend time of hearing and Owens needs to be deposed. Judge set Deposition to be on March 1st.  June 10th is new hearing date. Laura Owens claims in this hearing that she thought she was pregnant in November, but found out later that she had a miscarriage "1 to 2 months prior". Her statement from the November 2nd hearing contradicts that claim. Steve Carbone (Reality Steve) also claims that in correspondence with her, she claims she was still pregnant in December. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX5bm_6llB4</ref> You can watch the status conference [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3iE4jUMAUA&t=622s here].


'''February 22:''' It was discovered that Laura M. Owens' December 8th post on Medium had been edited from what she posted initially. On her original December 7th post, she initially included "However, I won't be sharing updates regarding the status of my pregnancy with Clayton. ''I kindly ask not to receive congratulations or engage in discussions about Clayton and my pregnancy.'' This post is not intended for that purpose." She has since removed that portion of her post. The original post and the edited post are both linked [https://archive.ph/LfNgr here] and [https://archive.ph/UScEl here].   
'''February 22:''' It was discovered that Laura M. Owens' December 8th post on Medium had been edited from what she posted initially. On her original December 7th post, she initially included "However, I won't be sharing updates regarding the status of my pregnancy with Clayton. ''I kindly ask not to receive congratulations or engage in discussions about Clayton and my pregnancy.'' This post is not intended for that purpose." She has since removed that portion of her post. The original post and the edited post are both linked [https://archive.ph/LfNgr here] and [https://archive.ph/UScEl here].   
Line 159: Line 212:
'''April 1''': After Gingras's Motion for Extension of Time was denied by Judge Mata,<ref>[[:File:Mata Motion1.pdf]]</ref> the April 1st deadline passed with no response from Owens' side.   
'''April 1''': After Gingras's Motion for Extension of Time was denied by Judge Mata,<ref>[[:File:Mata Motion1.pdf]]</ref> the April 1st deadline passed with no response from Owens' side.   


'''April 8:''' Owens' attorney, David Gingras, files a [[:File:Motion to Compel.pdf|Motion to Compel Lunch and for Alternative Relief]].    
'''April 8:''' Owens' attorney, David Gingras, files a Motion to Compel Lunch and for Alternative Relief.<ref>[[:File:Motion to Compel.pdf]]</ref> The motion was denied by Judge Mata.<ref>[[:File:2024.05.01 Court Copy Unredacted Lunch Motion Denied.pdf]]</ref> 
 
'''April 10:''' Owens' bar complaint against Gregg Woodnick was released on the Justice for Clayton Reddit page.<ref>[[:File:24-0263 Public record Redacted compressed.pdf]]</ref>    


'''April 10:''' Owens' [[:File:24-0263 Public record Redacted compressed.pdf|bar complaint against Gregg Woodnick]] was released on the Justice for Clayton Reddit page.   
'''April 24:''' Dave Neal files a bar complaint against David Gingras, which was ultimately dismissed. You can read the full bar complaint file [[:File:24-1199 GINGRAS Public Record.pdf|here]].   


'''April 25:''' [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JlrtQqtYR9I&list=RDCMUCpHHJHwi5kwPNBC7qNz_pUg&start_radio=1 A livestream video by Dave Neal and Megan Fox] reveal several inconsistencies in Owens' pregnancy stories, including a Fiverr logo left on an ultrasound she purports to be her own, an audio recording which shows that the ultrasound she claims is fake was actually from her, and two different copies of the same HCG test from October 16, 2023 which show two extremely different levels.   
'''April 25:''' [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JlrtQqtYR9I&list=RDCMUCpHHJHwi5kwPNBC7qNz_pUg&start_radio=1 A livestream video by Dave Neal and Megan Fox] reveal several inconsistencies in Owens' pregnancy stories, including a Fiverr logo left on an ultrasound she purports to be her own, an audio recording which shows that the ultrasound she claims is fake was actually from her, and two different copies of the same HCG test from October 16, 2023 which show two extremely different levels.   


== [[Laura Owens' court cases|Links to all court documents]] ==
'''April 30:''' Owens' lawyer, David Gingras, files a Motion in Limine to keep Laura's 3 past relationships from testifying at the trial.<ref>[[:File:2024.04.30 - Motion in Limine.pdf]]</ref> The motion was denied by Judge Mata.<ref>[[:File:5.22.24 ME Rulings.pdf]]</ref>   
 
'''May 1:''' Owen's bar complaint against her own previous lawyer, Lexi Lindvall, was released on the Justice for Clayton Reddit page.<ref>[[:File:24-0341 Public record Lindvall BarComplaint Redacted.pdf]]</ref> 
 
'''May 2:''' Dave Neal reveals in a video that Laura sent text messages to her previous boyfriend, Michael Marraccini, claiming that she had cancer and had an ovary removed. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Qjb1HkeVro&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=135</ref> 
 
'''May 3:''' Laura submits an affadavit to the court stating that she never sent the messages to Marraccini and has no idea who did, but they are obviously fake.<ref>[[:File:2024.05.03 Laura Affidavit w Exhibit A (redacted).pdf]]</ref> 
 
'''May 4:''' Dave Neal and Megan Fox put together a fundraiser for a forensic investigator to analyze Marraccini's laptop.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/live/jSIyhIWeTWY</ref> 
 
'''May 7:''' The forensic report was released to the public, stating that they found the images to come from the phone number attached to Laura Owens.<ref>[[:File:Marraccini Laptop Forensic Report.pdf]]</ref> 
 
'''May 10:''' Laura Michelle Owens' lawyer, David Gingras, had a phone call with someone at the State Bar of Arizona regarding a bar complaint that was filed on him by Dave Neal. It was ultimately dismissed and closed. [[:File:DN Bar Complaint Response to DG Redacted.pdf|You can read the email confirming that here]]. 
 
'''May 24:''' A new lawyer on YouTube, [https://www.youtube.com/live/pIKC1pbfDJA The Tilted Lawyer], begins covering the case after receiving communication from both Owens and people from Echard's side. 
 
'''May 28:''' Laura releases a new blog on her lawyer's website, detailing the cyberbullying she claims to be enduring.<ref>https://web.archive.org/web/20240530164457/https://gingraslaw.com/hated-in-the-nation-lauras-version/</ref>
 
'''May 31:''' A member of the JFC community reveals that they were able to confirm that Chase J. Jones is directly tied to Laura M. Owens. They were able to tie Chase's YouTube account to Laura's phone number. Another member was able to tie an email address of Chase J. Jones to Laura's phone number as well.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPCIZhg8FJk</ref>
 
'''June 3:''' Megan Fox reveals that another alleged victim of Laura's named Tag has been emailing Fox over the last month telling their story. She reads the emails live and there are many facts that don't seem to add up. When Megan repeatedly asks for Tag to verify their identity, Tag stops responding. Tag also reached out to another content creator, Lauren Neidigh. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gsdb-1a8gh8</ref>
 
'''June 10:''' Evidentiary hearing took place. Judge Mata is currently reviewing all evidence and will submit a ruling at a later date. You can rewatch the trial [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rgDD-6h0HgA here]. Before the trial, Laura's lawyer, David S. Gingras, contacted the Phoenix police on Michael Marraccini who was there as a subpoenaed witness. The police came, but took no action. 
 
'''June 11:''' Laura called the Scottsdale PD, claiming that all three men (Clayton, Greg, and Mike) violated their OOPs. You can listen to that call [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aRhOXKx5IgU here.] 
 
'''June 18: Judge Mata gave her ruling, stating that the Court cannot find that Laura Owens was ever pregnant with Clayton Echard's child/children and cannot establish paternity of a non-confirmed pregnancy. She also found that Laura Owens filed the case in bad faith, not grounded in fact or based in law, provided false testimony, and threatened to sue Clayton Echard for $1.4M in collateral allegations. The ruling states that Laura Owens must pay all of Clayton Echard's attorney fees and costs related to this case, but denied the attorney fees and costs for the IAH and OOP hearings. Furthermore, Judge Mata is referring this matter to the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office for review of Laura Owens' actions, as the Court has determined that Laura Owens has a pattern of similar, if not identical behavior, and court involvement.<ref>[[:File:2024.06.18 - Final Ruling.pdf]]</ref>'''
 
'''June 19:''' Laura Michelle Owens writes a [https://archive.ph/EAm5w blog post on Medium]. The blog includes the narrative that Judge Mata is wrong and is making a harmful precedent for future cases. For comparison and added context, please check the [[:File:2024.06.18 - Final Ruling.pdf|June 10th ruling]].   
 
'''June 20:''' Laura Owens posts on her [https://archive.ph/7ipxi Nobody Told Me podcast Facebook page], doubling down on her viewpoints about Judge Mata's ruling.   
 
'''June 21:''' Laura Owens makes another [https://web.archive.org/web/20240622022330/https://medium.com/@laura_owens/dont-tell-me-i-wasn-t-abused-you-weren-t-there-7b5b22340340 Medium blog post], discussing her relationship with Michael Marraccini.   
 
'''June 22:''' Laura Owens posts another [https://web.archive.org/web/20240623025555/https://medium.com/@laura_owens/dear-jfc-cult-lets-talk-about-your-too-honest-leader-7d230d5817b0 Medium blog post], discussing how Clayton lied to her concerning her real estate offers. Sidenote: This was covered in trial and he admitted to his wrongdoing.       
 
'''June 24:''' [https://www.instagram.com/reel/C8nd7jmyWFl/?igsh=YTgxYjl1aHJhcDZm Clayton Echard announces that he is started a podcast], focusing on "real men having real discussions". Laura Owens posts yet another [https://web.archive.org/web/20240624235421/https://medium.com/@laura_owens/when-common-sense-is-overruled-197a429c1041 Medium blog post], once again attacking Judge Mata, Clayton Echard, and the justice seekers that are following this case.       
 
'''June 25:''' [https://archive.md/Nh7Ke Laura Owens posts another blog], stating that she is being cyberbullied daily by the  "JFC Cult".       
 
''*It should be noted that those of us that contribute to this mediawiki page vehemently oppose any and all cyberbullying. We believe that the court documents speak for themselves, and choose to only focus on the legal aspects of these cases.''
 
'''June 28:''' Clayton Echard appears on the local NBC affiliate, 12 News, to discuss the paternity case. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dr7lemG94Rk&t=10s You may watch the video here.]
 
'''July 8:''' Laura Michelle Owens' attorney files a Notice of Change of Judge for Cause and a Memorandum & Affidavit. In the filing, Laura and her lawyer blast Judge Mata and state she was biased throughout the hearing and asks for a new judge to take on her case. <ref>[[:File:Notice for Change of Judge and Gingras Affadavit Redacted compressed.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''July 8:''' On the same day, Clayton Echard's attorneys file the Application for Attorneys' Fees & Cost. This is the amount that Laura Michelle Owens will be required by law to pay, given the outcome of the June 10th trial. The total amount Echard's attorneys are filing equal $154,242.76.<ref>[[:File:Application for Attorney Fees and Cost Redacted.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''July 11:''' Clayton's attorneys file a Response to Notice of Change of Judge for Cause.<ref>[[:File:2024.07.11 - RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF CHANGE OF JUDGE FOR CAUSE Redacted.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''July 12:''' Laura Michelle Owens' attorney files several motions: Motion to Vacate Judgment, Motion for New Trial, Motion to Alter/Amend Judgment, and Motion for Leave to Exceed Page Limits. <ref>[[:File:2024.07.12 - MOTION TO VACATE JUDGMENT; MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL, ETC. Redacted.pdf]]</ref>
 
'''July 18:''' Clayton Echard goes on [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2VPXEPKqmE&t=3s Reality Steve's podcast] and discusses the case.       
 
'''July 22:''' It is discovered by the Seeking Justice for All Victims of Laura Owens account on Twitter/X that Laura Michelle Owens' article in Chicken Soup for the Soul has been removed. This article discusses her relationship with Mike Marraccini, their trip to Iceland, and her claims of verbal, emotional, and physical abuse. Additionally, the Chicken Soup for the Soul podcast she did talking about her article has also been removed.<ref>https://x.com/ClaytonsJustice/status/1815511703146160143</ref><ref><nowiki>https://chartable.com/podcasts/chicken-soup-for-the-soul-with-amy-newmark/episodes/147337085-strangers-on-a-plane-and-the-lifesaving-power-of-kindness</nowiki></ref>       
 
'''August 5:''' The Maricopa County Attorney's office sends out a message on X/Twitter stating: "We have received a number of inquiries from the public concerning the matter involving Laura Owens. Here is the updated status: Upon receiving the minute entry from the superior court judge, this office began an investigation into the matter. Because of the volume of information, any investigation, done correctly, is going to take time.  We are working diligently to review the materials and will release results when it is appropriate to do so."<ref>https://x.com/marcoattorney/status/1820550312400400801</ref>       
 
'''August 13:''' Honorable Ronda R. Fisk denies Laura's Notice of Change of Judge for Cause.<ref>[[:File:Fisk Ruling.pdf]]</ref>       
 
'''August 14:''' Several YouTube content creators (Dave Neal, That Umbrella Guy, and Lauren Neidigh) announce that Laura Michelle Owens tried to claim that them using a photo of her in their video thumbnails are copyright infringement. YouTube denied all 3 of her claims. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ar22xqfjzT0</ref><ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6PnLjL8o2M&t=1028s</ref><ref>https://x.com/ThatUmbrella/status/1823665453119521161</ref>       
 
'''September 5:''' Laura Owens files a Notice of Appeal for her paternity case against Clayton Echard.<ref>[[:File:FC2023-052114 GINGRAS NOTICE OF APPEAL 2024-09-05 Redacted.pdf]]</ref>       
 
'''September 16:''' Laura Michelle Owens releases a new blog post on the Medium website titled "[https://web.archive.org/web/20240917011040/https://medium.com/@laura_owens/i-was-just-diagnosed-with-autism-and-it-explains-everything-3e281adbc043 I Was Just Diagnosed with Autism - And It Explains Everything"]. She goes on to say she has autism, but does not describe how it relates to her actions involving her court cases. This sparks outrage amongst the Justice for Clayton community, because autism does not describe the lying and deceit related to the court cases.       
 
'''September 17:''' Judge Mata files a bar complaint against Laura Owens' attorney, David Gingras. [[:File:Judge Mata's Bar Complaint against David Gingras.pdf|You can read portions of that complaint here.]]       
 
'''September 19''': A member of the Justice for Clayton community pens a response to Laura's blog post, entitled "[https://medium.com/@blowqueen/laura-owens-using-miserable-misstatements-to-dodge-prosecution-f162c524706b Laura Owens: Using Miserable 'Misstatements' to Dodge Prosecution]".       
 
'''October 11:''' The appeal is officially filed in the Court of Appeals - Division 2.<ref>https://www.appeals2.az.gov/ODSPlus/caseInfolast.cfm?caseID=134195</ref>       
 
'''October 15:''' A popular podcast, [https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/part-1-the-legal-drama-behind-the-bachelor/id1549568903?i=1000673286654 The Bravo Docket, releases a 2 part podcast] covering the Clayton Echard & Laura Owens paternity scandal.       
 
'''November 14:''' Laura Owens' attorney files their appeal to the June 10th decision. [[:File:Gingras-Appeal-compressed.pdf|You can read that here.]]
 
'''November 17:''' Mike Marraccini files a bar complaint against Laura Owens' attorney. [[:File:2024 11 17 Mike s bar complaint Redacted.pdf|You can read that here.]]       
 
=== ''[[Laura Michelle Owens - Court Case Documents|Links to all court documents]]'' ===


== References ==
== References ==


<references />
<references />

Latest revision as of 21:24, 21 November 2024

Clayton Echard, star of season 26 of The Bachelor, had a one-night fling (allegedly just oral sex, according to him) with Laura Owens on May 20, 2023. 11 days later, after he refuses to pursue a relationship with her, she claims she is pregnant. Laura drafted a dating contract to give to Clayton stating she would abort the baby if he agreed to date her, but he still refused. On August 1st, she took him to court to establish a "parenting plan" for the babies (now twins), and sent upwards of 500 emails and texts to him from more than a dozen different accounts. She went public with the case in September when he still refused to date her. She claims under oath on November 2nd that she is 24 weeks and just saw her OB a few days prior. Laura and Clayton are both granted orders of protection against one another. As of December 28th, she claimed she was "no longer pregnant", and sought to dismiss the court case. Because Clayton believed she fraudulently brought the situation into court and did not have evidence to prove she was actually pregnant with his child(ren), Clayton sought to be awarded attorney's fees.

On Monday June 10th, 2024, the evidentiary hearing took place. On June 18th, Judge Mata gave her ruling, stating that the Court cannot find that Laura Michelle Owens was ever pregnant with Clayton Echard's child/children and cannot establish paternity of a non-confirmed pregnancy. She also found that Laura Owens filed the case in bad faith, not grounded in fact or based in law, provided false testimony, and attempted to extort Clayton Echard. The ruling states that Laura Owens must pay all of Clayton Echard's attorney fees and costs related to this case, but denied the attorney fees and costs for the IAH and OOP hearings. Furthermore, Judge Mata is referring this matter to the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office for review of Laura Owens' actions.

Timeline of events

A detailed timeline of all of Clayton Echard's court cases against Laura Owens, including screenshots of texts and emails, can be found at justiceforclaytontimeline.com..

2023

April 3: Clayton Echard announces on Instagram that he has become a real estate agent, serving the Phoenix and Scottsdale areas. [1]

May 9: Laura Owens creates an LLC for the purpose of Real Estate and Rental and Leasing. [2]

May 17: Owens reaches out to Clayton Echard on LinkedIn for real estate assistance.[3]

May 20: After an exchange of flirty text messages, which Clayton claims involved a racy photo sent by Laura, Clayton invites Laura over. The two have an “intimate encounter,” which Echard describes as “only oral sex.” The following day, Echard tells Owens that the hook up was a "mistake." [4]

May 21: Clayton makes his intentions clear, that he does not want to pursue a relationship with her. He apologizes for crossing the professional/personal boundary. She breaks down in tears and refuses to accept it. She asks to have him continue to be her realtor.[5]

May 22: Owens starts telling Echard that she cannot continue to have him be her realtor if he doesn't want to pursue a relationship. He consistently tells her he will assign her to another realtor, but she will not accept.[5]

May 25: Echard asks Owens to leave him alone, informing her that he is considering contacting the police. He blocks her phone number.[5]

May 30: Laura states that she took a pregnancy test before a CT scan and it was negative.[6]

May 31: Laura takes a home pregnancy (hCG) test again. She at first states that it was negative[7], but later claims that she saw a "faint" positive line[8], so decided to go get another test done at a medical facility the next day.

June 1: Laura went to Banner Urgent Care for a pregnancy (hCG) test, and tested positive. 11 days after their “intimate encounter,” Owens emails Echard a photo of her first positive pregnancy test. [9]

June 4: Clayton reaches out to Jan Black (Laura's mother). Clayton asks her several times via text if they can talk on the phone, but she refuses and says she will only talk to him if he gives her daughter a chance at a relationship. [10]

June 17: Echard purchases a pregnancy test and asked Owens to take in front of him to confirm the pregnancy. She goes to the bathroom and the result comes out positive. [9]

June 21: Clayton emails Laura, citing research he's looked into that some seizure medication can give false positives on pregnancy tests. Laura denies that. Clayton also states in this email that they only had oral sex (something he has consistently stated).[7]

June 27: Owens' "Iceland story" is published in Chicken Soup for the Soul. [11]

June 28: Laura emails Clayton to say she's "having the baby if I don't hear back from you tonight". She says in her email that she wants to date him and will get an abortion if he agrees to, or she will throw the abortion pills away if he refuses. He responded saying he wants nothing to do with her and to please leave him alone.[12]

July 2: Owens emails Echard’s parents inviting them to her ultrasound. [9] Laura said in her affidavit on 4/16/24 that she went to Planned Parenthood in Mission Viejo on this day. [8] Planned Parenthood replies to Gregg Woodnick, stating that Laura Owens did have an appt at a location on July 2nd, but she canceled it.[13] According to Laura's testimony at the June 10th trial, she changed her story and stated that she actually went to a Planned Parenthood in LA on this day. [14] (It should be noted that Planned Parenthoods in LA are closed on Sundays.)

July 7: Owens sends Clayton a photo of her alleged ultrasound. You can view that ultrasound during Clayton's interview with the Viall Files at the 1 hr and 23 minute mark here.

Note: The ultrasound attempts to date the pregnancy using the date that the intimate encounter happened, not the date of the last menstrual period, which is the standard of care for pregnancy dating across OB/GYNs.

July 23: According to Laura Owens and her attorney David S. Gingras, Laura passes two "less than hand-sized fetal sacs" on this date. She allegedly sought medical attention via a telehealth doc and they told her there was no need to go in. She also allegedly texted photos of these fetal sacs to her sister on this day, and sent them to her doctor. In later filings, she claimed that she and her sister Laura Navarro had deleted the pictures, and refused to turn them over in discovery.[15]

July 24: Laura allegedly had a scheduled appointment with Dr. Makhoul to "hear the heartbeat". Since there is no documentation of this appointment, it is assumed that she canceled it.[16]

July 31: Laura files a police report with Scottsdale PD, stating Clayton has been "threatening, intimidating, verbally abusing, endangering, and extorting her". She wanted to have it on record. Refers to Clayton as the father of her unborn twins. This is also when the officer suggests blocking his number, but she said that she didn't want to because she "wants to know what he's thinking". [17]

August 1: Owens files Petition to Establish Paternity against Echard in Maricopa County Family Court. [18]

August 3: Owens emails Arizona Suicide Prevention Hope Conference to get Echard removed as a guest speaker. [9]

August 8: Owens files first "Motion to Communicate" and Child Support Worksheet[19]

August 14: Laura cancels her appt. set with Dr. Makhoul (an ob/gyn) for the following day, stating she has covid. [20]

August 17: Owens emails Echard, warning that she will be filing a "Motion to Contempt" if he does not agree to meet up with her privately.[21]

August 21: Echard answers Owens' Petition to Establish Paternity.[22]

August 23: Laura initially scheduled their respective tests with Ravgen, but ended up canceling them.[23] Clayton was unaware of the cancelation until he called the day before. Also on this day, Laura Michelle Owens files a Motion for Contempt.[24]

August 27: Owens completes 4 Hour Co-Parenting and Divorce Class and files Parent Education Certificate with the Family Court.[25]

August 29: Owens files second "Motion to Communicate"[26]

September 11: Owens provides information about the case to a reporter from the New York Post via email.[27]

September 13: Newly created Reddit account u/Training-Trade4145 attempts to post four threads, titled "Clayton scandal?!"[28], "Clayton...the dad?!?!"[29], "Clayton...the dad?!"[30], and "Clayton...the dad?!"[31], on the subreddit r/BachelorNation. Two days later, the account again attempts to post multiple posts about the "Clayton scandal" in a different subreddit r/thebachelor. All posts were removed by the moderators.[32]

September 14: Owens files an Expedited Motion to Seal Court Record because "the media outlets New York Post and Page Six have expressed interest in publicizing the case." [33]

September 15: Arizona Real Estate Department sends Echard a notice that he violated realtor conduct. This was after Owens filed a complaint against him a month earlier. They issued Clayton a "non-disciplinary letter" and closed the case.[34] [35]

September 18: Owens goes to the Sun and Medium with an anonymous article. [36] [37] [38] This was released the 2nd day of Echard filming a new pickleball show.[5]

September 21: Owens posts "I am the anonymous woman in the Clayton scandal. Here's the proof. Here's my story:" on Reddit[7] with a link to her original Medium article of the same name. She provides other Redditors with links to her public Dropbox with photos of her pregnant belly and texts/emails from Echard.

September 21: Clayton posts on his Instagram story a receipt from Ravgen for scheduling the paternity test. Clayton also posts that other individuals have identical accusations against them from this individual.

September 22: Fortify Legal Services sends a cease and desist letter to Clayton regarding the Instagram story mentioned above.

September 22: Laura calls Scottsdale PD regarding Clayton being on Reddit. Her mother, Jan Black, can be heard in the background calling Clayton a "joke".[39]

September 26: Clayton files Petition for Injunction Against Harassment against Laura Michelle Owens.[40]

September 27: Echard takes his side of paternity test. Owens is photographed competing in an Equestrian jumping competition — allegedly 20 weeks pregnant with twins. No baby bump seen. [41] [42]

October 6: DNA test results come back. Echard announces “little to no fetal DNA” on his Instagram story. [43] Owens claims the results were “ongoing” and recorded a call with the lab to support that. [44]

It is important to note that all of Owens’ DNA tests returned the same result of “little to no fetal DNA.”

October 6: Owens files OOP against Echard. You can watch that short hearing here, or read the transcript here.

October 6: Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD about Clayton harassing her online. [45]

October 7: Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that Greg Gillespie is behind Reddit accounts that are posting about her.[46]

October 8: Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that Greg Gillespie is behind Reddit accounts that are posting about her.[47]

October 9: Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that Greg Gillespie is behind Reddit accounts that are posting about her.[48]

October 10: Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD stating that she was "violated cyberly" (she doesn't state by whom).[49]

October 13: Dave Neal breaks the story that on October 11th, Owens had circulated her alleged sonogram video to Clayton as well as to the media, which was later proved to be an edited 6 year old sonogram from an unrelated Youtuber. There were several things off about the ultrasound video, which are shown on Neal's video. [50] Owens later claims Greg Gillespie hacked into her account and released the fake sonogram.

October 16: Laura Owens has an HCG test done, showing that her HCG levels on this day, at 21+ weeks pregnant, were 102 mIU/mL.[51]

October 19: Laura sends Dave Neal a cease and desist letter for his coverage. [52]

October 19: Laura also calls the Scottsdale PD on Clayton, stating that Clayton has violated his OOP by posting the October 6th Instagram story. It should be noted that the OOP did not go in effect until October 17th.[53]

October 24: The first part of the Echard vs. Owens IAH case takes place. Laura appears virtually, while her lawyer and Clayton, who is self-representing at the time, appear in court. Judge Gialketsis determines that the hearing must continue on November 2nd because Laura's lawyer failed to give Clayton some of the documents in advance. You can watch the hearing here.

October 25: Owens vs. Echard OOP case takes place. Laura appears in person with a large pregnant bump. Judge Doody upholds the OOP against Clayton, specifically stating that costume image released on Reddit being the main cause for upholding it. Clayton denies that he is the one that uploaded that image. Laura testifies to Judge Doody that Clayton is the only one that has that image, so could be the only person that could have done that. She failed to testify that she made her dropbox public, which means that dozens of Redditors also had access to the image. She also states 2 weeks later in a police report that Greg Gillespie was the one that uploaded the costume image.[54][55] It's also worth nothing that the person that did create the image stated on X that they were the one responsible for the image, and were verified to be neither Clayton nor Greg. You can watch the hearing here.

October 26: Owens files for a temporary restraining order against Neal. The judge denies the request on first amendment concerns. [56]

November 1: Laura contacts the Scottsdale PD claiming that she's being stalked and harassed online, and that she suspects it's either Greg or Clayton. She also states that she thinks somebody tried to break into her rental property.[57]

November 2: The second part of Clayton's IAH takes place. Clayton is now represented by Deandra Arena from Woodnick Law. Echard wins his injunction against harassment hearing. Owens states in cross-examination that she was 24 weeks pregnant and had just seen her OB "last Friday". Owens is seen drinking an energy drink during the hearing, which is unadvised to do during a pregnancy. Echard claims that Owens got him fired from speaking gigs and reported him to the Real Estate commission. Judge Gialketsis sides with Echard due to the 500+ messages/emails he received from her after he asked her to stop contacting him and blocked her. [58] You can watch the hearing here.

November 3: Dave Neal is served lawsuit from Owens alleging harassment and revenge porn. The photo she cites as revenge porn, was shared by Owens in her public Dropbox “evidence” folder, which she sent to various media outlets, as well as in Bachelor related subreddits. [59]

November 6: Video surfaces of Owens’ alleged baby belly moving wildly during court hearing against Echard, 27 days after she was photographed without a bump at horse jumping competition. [60]

November 9: Judge throws out Owens’ suit for emotional damage against Greg Gillespie. [61] News leaks that Laura Owens is trying to change her name to Emily Wilson.[62]

November 10: Owens filed a police report on Gillespie for violating his OOP by allegedly posting her private information to Reddit under various alt accounts. Detectives found no evidence of her claims and closed the police investigation. (#23–20074) [63]

November 14: Owens sends mass email to podcasters threatening to sue them for defamation if they cover the case without platforming her. [64]

November 14: Laura Michelle Owens attends a dr appt at MomDoc. They give her a pregnancy test and confirm that she is not pregnant.[65]

November 15: Reality Steve offers Owens a platform to share her story. She does not accept his offer and instead threatens to sue him.

November 18: Owens pulls out of The Las Vegas National (horse jumping competition) after it leaks on Reddit that she was signed up to compete while allegedly six months pregnant with twins. [66]

It has been rumored that she then attempted to compete under an alias — but that rumor has not been corroborated.

December 4: Owens and Echard’s paternity case gets moved to the inactive calendar because of a lack of movement in the case. [67]

December 5: Law Talk with Mike covers the case and offers Owens a platform to prove her pregnancy. She does not accept, instead threatens to sue him. [68]

December 6: Neal breaks the news that a third DNA test came back with the same result of “little to no fetal DNA.” [69] Around this time, Owens submits criminal complaint against Neal with Los Angeles District Attorney. [70]

December 8: Owens publishes blog post to Medium titled "Unveiling the Unbearable: My Battle Against Cyberbullying and Online Harassment | by Laura Owens" [71]

December 8: Laura calls the Scottsdale PD claiming that Clayton has violated his OOP by posting something online. [72]

December 12: Echard files a motion in family court to extend the dismissal date, to definitively, on record, settle if he is or is not the father of Laura Owens' alleged twins.[73] Also, a welfare check is done on Laura Michelle Owens, after an anonymous friend calls the Scottsdale PD because of her Medium article written on 12/8. You can watch the body cam footage of this welfare check here. (Note: They never actually see Laura during this welfare check, just her mother.)

December 20: Owens posts a public video on her Facebook page which opens with "My name is Laura Owens..." and proceeds to speak for over 6 minutes about being "cyberbullied". The video is shot from her neck up. The sounds she makes are of a crying nature, but no tears are actually seen for the entirety of the video. She specifically calls out Neal, Reality Steve, and "Reddit sleuths" for alleged cyberbullying. Owens also shared Patreon paid subscriber private stream footage of Neal saying things about her over the past few months without any context. Once again, let it be known that Neal has never once said her name (he refers to her as Jane Doe) or shown any photos of her. After about a half-hour, the video disappears from her public Facebook page and she claims that it was only intended for her close friends and family (her beginning the video with "My name is Laura Owens..." seems to dispute this claim).

December 21: The Medium article by Regina Phalange was taken down by Medium[74]. Interesting that Medium continues to leave up her defamatory post about Echard and Dave, then takes down Regina's cogent rebuttal of Owens' post.

December 23: Chase J. Jones (widely believed to be Owens - see below for details) submits to have his Google and Patreon subpoenas quashed, claiming that he has nothing to do with the case. [75] Dave's lawyer has reached out to "Chase J. Jones" several times, asking for a quick FaceTime to verify he is real and put this matter to bed, but has been met with silence on the other end.

December 25: Laura Owens sends a cease and desist letter to TikTok/YouTube personality, Liz Neptune, regarding the use of a video Owens had posted to Facebook that had been used in a TikTok video by a different creator (not Liz Neptune). That creator is not affiliated with Liz in any way, yet Owens claims that she has proof that they are, but has not provided that proof. Owens and Neptune engage in a brief email correspondence, ending with Neptune telling Owens to never contact her again. Owens reported the correspondence as harassment to Liz's local Sherriff's department. [76]

December 28: Owens retains a new attorney in the family court case against Echard, files to dismiss petition to establish paternity. Owens claims that she's "not now pregnant" and wants the case dropped. She is also saying in her motion that because a portion of Echard's legal fees were crowdsourced that he isn't entitled to any awarding of legal fees. [77]

2024

January 2: A new article[78] about the case is published in The Sun. Owens responds to the article, stating: "that she 'firmly stands by everything' she had previously claimed and that she had a positive pregnancy test at one point, which was also documented in court docs, that 'confirmed' her pregnancy and 'was corroborated by a test at a medical facility.'"

Laura also contacted the Scottsdale PD about Clayton's comments to The Sun, stating it was a violation of his OOP. [79]

Laura Michelle Owens files to quash her deposition from Echard and his attorneys. Owens' new attorney, Lexi Lindvall, withdraws as counsel just one week after she takes on the case. Shortly thereafter, Cory Keith becomes Laura's new attorney. Evidentiary Hearing is set by the court for February 27th. [80]

January 17: Laura fails to show up for her deposition. [81]

January 18: Laura calls the Scottsdale PD about harassing phone calls she's been receiving.[82]

January 26: Laura Michelle Owens formed a company named Stylete, LLC. The description of this company is unknown.

February 2: Clayton shows up for his deposition. Laura attends it as well. [83]

February 6: Clayton's lawyer files expedited motion to continue trial and motion for additional trial time.[83]

February 7: Laura Owens receives harassing Facebook posts from what appears to be a troll account. She calls the police about these Facebook posts. Audio of this public call can be found here. The public Scottsdale Police report can also be accessed here.

February 11: The account Justice for Clayton was banned from twitter (X), but reinstated a few days later.

February 12: Clayton's lawyer files expedited motion to set virtual status conference. [73]

February 14: On Laura's alleged due date, she posts a blog post about miscarriage that is so cruel, insensitive, heartless, immature, and irresponsible that we will not link it here. Also on this day, Laura called the Scottsdale PD about alleged online harassment. She specifically asks if her call cannot be public record, but the 911 operator tells her that 911 calls are public record. You can listen to the call here.

February 15: Status conference is set for February 21st.[73]

February 16: Judge denied Laura's motion to quash her deposition. [73] The next few days, the Justice for Clayton sub on Reddit was banned and reinstated twice.

February 21: Status Conference is held. Laura Owens and Clayton Echard were present. Judge denied: Motion to Seal and Dismiss. Judge approved: Extend time of hearing and Owens needs to be deposed. Judge set Deposition to be on March 1st. June 10th is new hearing date. Laura Owens claims in this hearing that she thought she was pregnant in November, but found out later that she had a miscarriage "1 to 2 months prior". Her statement from the November 2nd hearing contradicts that claim. Steve Carbone (Reality Steve) also claims that in correspondence with her, she claims she was still pregnant in December. [84] You can watch the status conference here.

February 22: It was discovered that Laura M. Owens' December 8th post on Medium had been edited from what she posted initially. On her original December 7th post, she initially included "However, I won't be sharing updates regarding the status of my pregnancy with Clayton. I kindly ask not to receive congratulations or engage in discussions about Clayton and my pregnancy. This post is not intended for that purpose." She has since removed that portion of her post. The original post and the edited post are both linked here and here.

February 27: Laura M. Owens emails Clayton's attorney, Gregg Woodnick, directly (instead of going through her lawyer, Cory Keith) stating that she intends to sue Echard for $1.4 million for breaches of contractual and fiduciary duties as well as emotional distress. She states in this email that she will not sue Clayton if he drops the family court case against her and that he has until the day before her deposition to agree to her terms. [85] Woodnick also mentions in his email that three of the doctors that Owens has claimed to have seen for her pregnancy have responded to the HIPAA request stating that they have no patient by the name of Laura Owens.

March 1: Laura M. Owens finally attends her deposition.

March 7: Echard releases a statement to the press, stating that Owens, during her deposition on March 1st, admitted to tampering the ultrasounds from Southwest Medical Imaging. The press release can be read in its entirety here. The Sun releases an article covering the forged pregnancy records.

March 11: Gregg Woodnick files a Motion to Compel. In this motion, Woodnick states that Laura claims to have passed two fetal sacks and has sent the picture to her sister and spoke to tele health sometime in September or October. However, no evidence has been shared by Laura.

March 12: Cory Keith submits a motion to withdraw as Owens' attorney, with client consent, making him the next in the ongoing list of attorneys that refuse to further represent her. Also, The Sun retracts their March 7th article, but lives forever here.

March 25: Gregg Woodnick files a Motion for Joint Hearing Pursuant to Rule 5(a)(4). This motion seeks to have the court rule if Laura's protective order against Clayton can be dismissed due to being founded on both implicit and explicit fraud. The motion seeks for the judge to conduct a joint hearing and order relief to Clayton as the court deems just.

March 26: The Maricopa County Family Court docket shows that Laura has retained new counsel after her former lawyer, Cory Keith, withdrew. Her new lawyer is David Gingras.

April 1: After Gingras's Motion for Extension of Time was denied by Judge Mata,[86] the April 1st deadline passed with no response from Owens' side.

April 8: Owens' attorney, David Gingras, files a Motion to Compel Lunch and for Alternative Relief.[87] The motion was denied by Judge Mata.[88]

April 10: Owens' bar complaint against Gregg Woodnick was released on the Justice for Clayton Reddit page.[89]

April 24: Dave Neal files a bar complaint against David Gingras, which was ultimately dismissed. You can read the full bar complaint file here.

April 25: A livestream video by Dave Neal and Megan Fox reveal several inconsistencies in Owens' pregnancy stories, including a Fiverr logo left on an ultrasound she purports to be her own, an audio recording which shows that the ultrasound she claims is fake was actually from her, and two different copies of the same HCG test from October 16, 2023 which show two extremely different levels.

April 30: Owens' lawyer, David Gingras, files a Motion in Limine to keep Laura's 3 past relationships from testifying at the trial.[90] The motion was denied by Judge Mata.[91]

May 1: Owen's bar complaint against her own previous lawyer, Lexi Lindvall, was released on the Justice for Clayton Reddit page.[92]

May 2: Dave Neal reveals in a video that Laura sent text messages to her previous boyfriend, Michael Marraccini, claiming that she had cancer and had an ovary removed. [93]

May 3: Laura submits an affadavit to the court stating that she never sent the messages to Marraccini and has no idea who did, but they are obviously fake.[94]

May 4: Dave Neal and Megan Fox put together a fundraiser for a forensic investigator to analyze Marraccini's laptop.[95]

May 7: The forensic report was released to the public, stating that they found the images to come from the phone number attached to Laura Owens.[96]

May 10: Laura Michelle Owens' lawyer, David Gingras, had a phone call with someone at the State Bar of Arizona regarding a bar complaint that was filed on him by Dave Neal. It was ultimately dismissed and closed. You can read the email confirming that here.

May 24: A new lawyer on YouTube, The Tilted Lawyer, begins covering the case after receiving communication from both Owens and people from Echard's side.

May 28: Laura releases a new blog on her lawyer's website, detailing the cyberbullying she claims to be enduring.[97]

May 31: A member of the JFC community reveals that they were able to confirm that Chase J. Jones is directly tied to Laura M. Owens. They were able to tie Chase's YouTube account to Laura's phone number. Another member was able to tie an email address of Chase J. Jones to Laura's phone number as well.[98]

June 3: Megan Fox reveals that another alleged victim of Laura's named Tag has been emailing Fox over the last month telling their story. She reads the emails live and there are many facts that don't seem to add up. When Megan repeatedly asks for Tag to verify their identity, Tag stops responding. Tag also reached out to another content creator, Lauren Neidigh. [99]

June 10: Evidentiary hearing took place. Judge Mata is currently reviewing all evidence and will submit a ruling at a later date. You can rewatch the trial here. Before the trial, Laura's lawyer, David S. Gingras, contacted the Phoenix police on Michael Marraccini who was there as a subpoenaed witness. The police came, but took no action.

June 11: Laura called the Scottsdale PD, claiming that all three men (Clayton, Greg, and Mike) violated their OOPs. You can listen to that call here.

June 18: Judge Mata gave her ruling, stating that the Court cannot find that Laura Owens was ever pregnant with Clayton Echard's child/children and cannot establish paternity of a non-confirmed pregnancy. She also found that Laura Owens filed the case in bad faith, not grounded in fact or based in law, provided false testimony, and threatened to sue Clayton Echard for $1.4M in collateral allegations. The ruling states that Laura Owens must pay all of Clayton Echard's attorney fees and costs related to this case, but denied the attorney fees and costs for the IAH and OOP hearings. Furthermore, Judge Mata is referring this matter to the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office for review of Laura Owens' actions, as the Court has determined that Laura Owens has a pattern of similar, if not identical behavior, and court involvement.[100]

June 19: Laura Michelle Owens writes a blog post on Medium. The blog includes the narrative that Judge Mata is wrong and is making a harmful precedent for future cases. For comparison and added context, please check the June 10th ruling.

June 20: Laura Owens posts on her Nobody Told Me podcast Facebook page, doubling down on her viewpoints about Judge Mata's ruling.

June 21: Laura Owens makes another Medium blog post, discussing her relationship with Michael Marraccini.

June 22: Laura Owens posts another Medium blog post, discussing how Clayton lied to her concerning her real estate offers. Sidenote: This was covered in trial and he admitted to his wrongdoing.

June 24: Clayton Echard announces that he is started a podcast, focusing on "real men having real discussions". Laura Owens posts yet another Medium blog post, once again attacking Judge Mata, Clayton Echard, and the justice seekers that are following this case.

June 25: Laura Owens posts another blog, stating that she is being cyberbullied daily by the "JFC Cult".

*It should be noted that those of us that contribute to this mediawiki page vehemently oppose any and all cyberbullying. We believe that the court documents speak for themselves, and choose to only focus on the legal aspects of these cases.

June 28: Clayton Echard appears on the local NBC affiliate, 12 News, to discuss the paternity case. You may watch the video here.

July 8: Laura Michelle Owens' attorney files a Notice of Change of Judge for Cause and a Memorandum & Affidavit. In the filing, Laura and her lawyer blast Judge Mata and state she was biased throughout the hearing and asks for a new judge to take on her case. [101]

July 8: On the same day, Clayton Echard's attorneys file the Application for Attorneys' Fees & Cost. This is the amount that Laura Michelle Owens will be required by law to pay, given the outcome of the June 10th trial. The total amount Echard's attorneys are filing equal $154,242.76.[102]

July 11: Clayton's attorneys file a Response to Notice of Change of Judge for Cause.[103]

July 12: Laura Michelle Owens' attorney files several motions: Motion to Vacate Judgment, Motion for New Trial, Motion to Alter/Amend Judgment, and Motion for Leave to Exceed Page Limits. [104]

July 18: Clayton Echard goes on Reality Steve's podcast and discusses the case.

July 22: It is discovered by the Seeking Justice for All Victims of Laura Owens account on Twitter/X that Laura Michelle Owens' article in Chicken Soup for the Soul has been removed. This article discusses her relationship with Mike Marraccini, their trip to Iceland, and her claims of verbal, emotional, and physical abuse. Additionally, the Chicken Soup for the Soul podcast she did talking about her article has also been removed.[105][106]

August 5: The Maricopa County Attorney's office sends out a message on X/Twitter stating: "We have received a number of inquiries from the public concerning the matter involving Laura Owens. Here is the updated status: Upon receiving the minute entry from the superior court judge, this office began an investigation into the matter. Because of the volume of information, any investigation, done correctly, is going to take time. We are working diligently to review the materials and will release results when it is appropriate to do so."[107]

August 13: Honorable Ronda R. Fisk denies Laura's Notice of Change of Judge for Cause.[108]

August 14: Several YouTube content creators (Dave Neal, That Umbrella Guy, and Lauren Neidigh) announce that Laura Michelle Owens tried to claim that them using a photo of her in their video thumbnails are copyright infringement. YouTube denied all 3 of her claims. [109][110][111]

September 5: Laura Owens files a Notice of Appeal for her paternity case against Clayton Echard.[112]

September 16: Laura Michelle Owens releases a new blog post on the Medium website titled "I Was Just Diagnosed with Autism - And It Explains Everything". She goes on to say she has autism, but does not describe how it relates to her actions involving her court cases. This sparks outrage amongst the Justice for Clayton community, because autism does not describe the lying and deceit related to the court cases.

September 17: Judge Mata files a bar complaint against Laura Owens' attorney, David Gingras. You can read portions of that complaint here.

September 19: A member of the Justice for Clayton community pens a response to Laura's blog post, entitled "Laura Owens: Using Miserable 'Misstatements' to Dodge Prosecution".

October 11: The appeal is officially filed in the Court of Appeals - Division 2.[113]

October 15: A popular podcast, The Bravo Docket, releases a 2 part podcast covering the Clayton Echard & Laura Owens paternity scandal.

November 14: Laura Owens' attorney files their appeal to the June 10th decision. You can read that here.

November 17: Mike Marraccini files a bar complaint against Laura Owens' attorney. You can read that here.

Links to all court documents

References

  1. ↑ https://www.instagram.com/p/CqlUFmJPRqu/
  2. ↑ https://ecorp.azcc.gov/BusinessSearch/BusinessInfo?entityNumber=23526876
  3. ↑ File:3 26 motion for joint hearing Redacted (1).pdf
  4. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fbof87l9rpsyb1.jpg
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zakKq3kUloc
  6. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/2/27/1-25_Woodnick_response_Redacted_compressed_%281%29.pdf
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 https://www.reddit.com/r/thebachelor/comments/16oxwn3/i_am_the_anonymous_woman_in_the_clayton_scandal/
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 File:2024.04.16 - Affidavit of Laura Owens.pdf
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf
  10. ↑ File:Texts messages between clayton and Jan.pdf
  11. ↑ https://chartable.com/podcasts/chicken-soup-for-the-soul-with-amy-newmark/episodes/147337085-strangers-on-a-plane-and-the-lifesaving-power-of-kindness
  12. ↑ File:Having the baby if I don't hear back tonight emails.pdf
  13. ↑ https://padlet.com/haybales/laura-owens-timeline-qz4pd706aw8m8zv3/wish/LNV1Q7Em1BY3Wmq3
  14. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNtMoU42K0E
  15. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/b/bf/Woodnick_response_4_10_compressed-1-9.pdf
  16. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r62n2sMW_K0&t=2365s
  17. ↑ File:2023.07.31 LO Police Call.pdf
  18. ↑ https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114
  19. ↑ https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114
  20. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/e/e1/REDACTED_Motion_for_extension_of_time_to_respond_Redacted.pdf
  21. ↑ Motion for Contempt, Page 22
  22. ↑ https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114
  23. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/e/ed/Motion_to_communicate_8_2023.pdf
  24. ↑ 2023.08.23 Motion for Contempt
  25. ↑ https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114
  26. ↑ 2023.08.29 - LO's Motion To Communicate
  27. ↑ LO Motion for Contempt, pgs. 26-28
  28. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/r/BachelorNation/comments/16i2n8a/clayton_scandal/
  29. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/r/BachelorNation/comments/16i2oki/claytonthe_dad/
  30. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/r/BachelorNation/comments/16i2pz8/claytonthe_dad/
  31. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/r/BachelorNation/comments/16i2pz8/claytonthe_dad/
  32. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/user/training-trade4145/submitted/
  33. ↑ 2023.09.14 - LO's Expedited Motion To Seal
  34. ↑ File:ADRE Letter to Echard.png
  35. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn-szJXMtr4&t=564s
  36. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf
  37. ↑ https://www.the-sun.com/tv/9120018/bachelor-clayton-echard-ex-paternity-test-pregnant-twins/
  38. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/4/47/Woodnick_response_1_19_%281%29.pdf
  39. ↑ File:E2309220172.pdf
  40. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/7/76/Clayton%27s_Injunction_Against_Harassment_against_Laura.pdf
  41. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/r/BachelorNation/comments/17lg27v/laura_michelle_owens_of_the_nobody_told_me/
  42. ↑ https://mccoolproofs.pixieset.com/2023blenheiminternationaljumpingfestival/p/OTkzNjYyNTIwMA==-MzAzODY0Mzc2NQ/
  43. ↑ https://www.the-sun.com/entertainment/9271392/bachelor-clayton-echard-paternity-test-results-pregnant-twins/
  44. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96FDgrs7Az0&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=5
  45. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNDaVf-eLsc
  46. ↑ File:E2310070115.pdf
  47. ↑ File:E2310080332.pdf
  48. ↑ File:E2310090293.pdf
  49. ↑ File:E2310100345.pdf
  50. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GyMuqht4sc&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=8
  51. ↑ File:Image.webp
  52. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VHnSaFYkd20&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=10
  53. ↑ File:2023.10.19 - Police Report - Owens accusing Echard of violating PO.pdf
  54. ↑ File:9.27.23 GG police report.pdf
  55. ↑ File:The Gillespie connection - color redacted - share.pdf
  56. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MVr0VAupjk&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=15
  57. ↑ File:E2311010426.pdf
  58. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r62n2sMW_K0&t=16s
  59. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2yNFYlt2A4&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=21
  60. ↑ https://imgur.com/a/wRzEynh
  61. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bj2pFDz3V4&t=1s
  62. ↑ https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/CivilCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=CV2023-054291
  63. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnKSYQiXVZA&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=29
  64. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-jWUDnG9s0&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=23
  65. ↑ File:Petitioners Expert Disclosure Statement Redacted 2.0 Part3.pdf
  66. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fwfjcj4t6sxxb1.jpg
  67. ↑ https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fgt6r04rn1c4c1.jpeg
  68. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vZ1IQxaC1Ho&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=31
  69. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmJXm_-9AQE&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=31
  70. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1Na9DIKbns&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=32
  71. ↑ https://medium.com/@laura_owens/unveiling-the-unbearable-my-battle-against-cyberbullying-and-online-harassment-eef20c9974dc
  72. ↑ File:2023.12.08 - LO Police Report.pdf
  73. ↑ 73.0 73.1 73.2 73.3 https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/FamilyCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=FC2023-052114
  74. ↑ https://archive.is/12Pfh
  75. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/6/60/2023.12.19_Chase_Jones_motion_to_quash_subpoenas.pdf
  76. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xQlbdtfoOE4
  77. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8t8Ax1lQsdQ&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=43
  78. ↑ https://www.the-sun.com/tv/9991743/bachelor-clayton-echard-fling-no-longer-pregnant-paternity-test/
  79. ↑ File:2024.01.02 - LO Police Call.pdf
  80. ↑ https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/docket/CivilCourtCases/caseInfo.asp?caseNumber=CV2023-054291
  81. ↑ https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/d/d7/Notice_of_non-appearancePDF.pdf
  82. ↑ File:2024.01.18 - LO Police Call.pdf
  83. ↑ 83.0 83.1 https://justiceforclayton.com/wiki/images/f/f5/2024.02.06_Expedited_Motion_to_Continue_Trial_and_Motion_for_Additional_Trial_Time.pdf
  84. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX5bm_6llB4
  85. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zeccXwr133w&t=312s
  86. ↑ File:Mata Motion1.pdf
  87. ↑ File:Motion to Compel.pdf
  88. ↑ File:2024.05.01 Court Copy Unredacted Lunch Motion Denied.pdf
  89. ↑ File:24-0263 Public record Redacted compressed.pdf
  90. ↑ File:2024.04.30 - Motion in Limine.pdf
  91. ↑ File:5.22.24 ME Rulings.pdf
  92. ↑ File:24-0341 Public record Lindvall BarComplaint Redacted.pdf
  93. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Qjb1HkeVro&list=PLocc5Mp7hk0mWMLzXpZT6kTG-E_ej33SF&index=135
  94. ↑ File:2024.05.03 Laura Affidavit w Exhibit A (redacted).pdf
  95. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/live/jSIyhIWeTWY
  96. ↑ File:Marraccini Laptop Forensic Report.pdf
  97. ↑ https://web.archive.org/web/20240530164457/https://gingraslaw.com/hated-in-the-nation-lauras-version/
  98. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPCIZhg8FJk
  99. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gsdb-1a8gh8
  100. ↑ File:2024.06.18 - Final Ruling.pdf
  101. ↑ File:Notice for Change of Judge and Gingras Affadavit Redacted compressed.pdf
  102. ↑ File:Application for Attorney Fees and Cost Redacted.pdf
  103. ↑ File:2024.07.11 - RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF CHANGE OF JUDGE FOR CAUSE Redacted.pdf
  104. ↑ File:2024.07.12 - MOTION TO VACATE JUDGMENT; MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL, ETC. Redacted.pdf
  105. ↑ https://x.com/ClaytonsJustice/status/1815511703146160143
  106. ↑ https://chartable.com/podcasts/chicken-soup-for-the-soul-with-amy-newmark/episodes/147337085-strangers-on-a-plane-and-the-lifesaving-power-of-kindness
  107. ↑ https://x.com/marcoattorney/status/1820550312400400801
  108. ↑ File:Fisk Ruling.pdf
  109. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ar22xqfjzT0
  110. ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6PnLjL8o2M&t=1028s
  111. ↑ https://x.com/ThatUmbrella/status/1823665453119521161
  112. ↑ File:FC2023-052114 GINGRAS NOTICE OF APPEAL 2024-09-05 Redacted.pdf
  113. ↑ https://www.appeals2.az.gov/ODSPlus/caseInfolast.cfm?caseID=134195
Retrieved from "http://justiceforclayton.com:80/wiki/index.php?title=Laura_Michelle_Owens_%26_Clayton_Echard&oldid=1628"